Tax law in the shadow of the higher judiciary – case study on Judicial Overreach | 14th June 2023 | UPSC Daily Editorial Analysis
What's the article about?
- It talks about the issue of judicial overreach due to the SC’s recent judgements pertaining to some tax laws.
Relevance:
- GS2: Structure, Organization and Functioning of the Executive and the Judiciary;
- Essay;
- Prelims
Context:
- Recently, in two different judgements, the SC believed that the parliament had overstepped its power to legislate on taxation.
- The writer of this article explains how these judgements are examples of judicial overreach.
- For our examination, facial information about these two laws related to taxes holds no importance. However, the philosophy of judicial overreach is important for our exam.
Theory of separation of powers:
- Indian Constitution provides for the separation of powers between three organs of the modern state – Executive, Legislative and Judiciary.
- Every organ is supreme in its own sphere, and it is ideal for them not to intervene in the spheres of others.
- However, due to exceptional circumstances, this ideal of separation of powers is not maintained.
- There have been instances where the judiciary has intervened in the legislative and executive spheres.
- These interventions are sometimes necessary, and other times they are considered transgressions by other two organs. (Judicial Activism, Restraint & Overreach).
Judicial Activism, Restraint and Overreach:
- Judicial activism signifies the proactive role of the Judiciary in protecting the rights of citizens. The practice of Judicial Activism first originated and developed in the USA.
- Judicial Restraint is the antithesis of Judicial Activism. Judicial Restraint is a theory of judicial interpretation that encourages judges to limit the exercise of their own power.
- When Judicial Activism goes overboard, and becomes Judicial Adventurism, it is referred to as Judicial Overreach.
- In simpler terms, it is when the judiciary starts interfering with the proper functioning of the legislative or executive organs of the government.
- Judicial Overreach is undesirable in a democracy as it breaches the principle of separation of powers.
Analysis:
- Basis of the Indian Taxation system:
- India’s law of taxation is built on two central precepts.
- First, on the idea captured in Article 265 of the Constitution, that a tax may be imposed only with the authority of law.
- Second, on a principle of sureness, that any levy ought to be clear, consistent, and predictable.
- Both these precepts emanate out of a larger commitment to the rule of law, in particular to values of legality and certainty.
- Judicial overreach:
- In two cases: ITO vs Vikram Sujitkumar Bhatia and Union of India vs Ashish Agarwal, the SC interpreted the provisions of the Income Tax Act, 1961.
- Through these judgments, it is believed that the SC is encroaching on legislative functions.
- Moreover, the SC used its extraordinary power – Article 142 of the Constitution – which allows it to pass orders for “doing complete justice to a cause”.
Way Forward:
- Article 265 of the Constitution forbids taxation without legislation. But if the Supreme Court is willing to play Parliament, this peremptory promise will remain illusory.
Recent Articles
- Government Schemes & Bodies 2024 Prelims 365
- Society 2024 Prelims 365
- Economy 2024 Prelims 365
- Polity 2024 Prelims 365
- Science and Technology 2024 Prelims 365
- International Relations 2024 Prelims 365
- History, Art and Culture 2024 Prelims 365
- Environment 2024 Prelims 365
- Most Important Acts, Bills in News 2024
- Most Important Places in News 2024
Popular Articles
- UPSC CSE 2023 Mains Essay Paper Model Answers
- UPSC CSE 2022 Mains GS 1 Paper Model Answers
- Storage, Transport & Marketing of Agricultural Produce & Issues & Related Constraints.
- Static Topics Repository for Mains
- Anti-Globalization Movement
- UPSC CSE 2023 Mains GS 1 Paper Model Answers
- UPSC CSE 2022 Mains GS 4 Paper Model Answers
- UPSC CSE 2023 Mains GS 2 Paper Model Answers
- PDS: objectives, functioning, limitations, revamping
- Achievements of Indians in Science & Technology
Popular Topics
ART & CULTURE
CASE STUDIES
COMMITTEES & SUMMITS
DISASTER MANAGEMENT
ECONOMICS
ECONOMICS PREMIUM
ECONOMICS STATIC
ECONOMIC SURVEY
EDITORIAL
ENVIRONMENT & ECOLOGY
ENVIRONMENT PREMIUM
ETHICS
GEOGRAPHY
GEOGRAPHY PREMIUM
GEOGRAPHY STATIC
HEALTH
HISTORY
HISTORY PREMIUM
HISTORY STATIC
INDIAN POLITY
INDIAN POLITY PREMIUM
INDIAN POLITY STATIC
INTEGRITY & APTITUDE
INTERNAL SECURITY & DEFENSE
INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS
LITE SUBSCRIPTION PREMIUM
MAINS
MAINS CORNER PREMIUM
PLUS SUBSCRIPTION PREMIUM
POLITY & GOVERNANCE
PRELIMS
PRELIMS CURRENT AFFAIRS MAGAZINE
PRO SUBSCRIPTION PREMIUM
REPORTS
SAMAJHO'S CORNER PREMIUM
SAMAJHO ANALYSIS
SAMAJHO CORNER PREMIUM
SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY
SELF PREPARATION
SMAP ANSWER WRITING
SOCIETY
SPR
SYLLABUS
TELEGRAM
YOJANA GIST